For you if: you drive a pickup such as an F-150, Silverado, Sierra, Ram 1500, Tundra, or Tacoma, and you are down to WeatherTech, Husky, and 3W. All three make liners cut for a specific year, make, and cab. Before you order, know your cab, whether the floor is carpet or vinyl, whether the front row is buckets or a bench, and whether the rear floor has a factory storage box.
Skip it if: you want a universal mat you trim with scissors, or you only need a carpet mat for looks. If you want our ranked picks across every brand, our best all-weather truck floor mats page covers that. This page answers one question, which is how these three brands compare head to head.
The Amazon buttons on the three cards below go to sets for a 2021–2026 F-150 SuperCrew, as an example fit. The Husky and 3W sets are the versions for trucks with the fold-flat rear storage, and the WeatherTech set is the version without it. On any other truck, buy the same product line cut for your year and cab.
Image: Husky Liners
01 · Best for most trucks and work trucks
Husky X-act Contour
This is the one we would buy for a truck that carries crews, dogs, and job-site mud.
Husky calls X-act Contour its most premium liner. It pairs a DuraGrip surface with Husky’s ProCore formula, and Husky says each liner is 3D laser-scanned to the vehicle’s floor.
In independent lab tests that Husky cites, done by September 2024 on liners for a 2018 F-150, X-act Contour was about 22% more flexible, more than 10% softer, and about 20% faster to clean than Husky WeatherBeater.
A raised FormFit Edge runs around the perimeter to hold water and dirt. Hundreds of StayPut nibs and the truck’s factory retention posts keep it in place. Husky lists a tool-free install of 15 minutes or less with no trimming.
Husky says it is made in the USA without latex, PVC, cadmium, or lead, and it carries Husky’s limited lifetime warranty.
Example fit: Husky 53468 is the three-piece front and second-row set for a 2021–2026 F-150 SuperCrew with factory carpet and the fold-flat rear storage. Husky also lists it for the F-150 Raptor and the 2022–2025 F-150 Lightning.
Catch: Husky also sells WeatherBeater, which Husky describes as its firmer, lower-priced line. Make sure the product name says X-act Contour if that is the liner you want.
This is the pick for a truck you keep clean, or one with a gray, tan, or cocoa interior you want the liners to match.
WeatherTech says FloorLiner HP is injection-molded from a rubber-like TPE and laser measured for each year, make, and model. It covers the bottom, front, back, and sides of the footwell.
The high walls have a beveled edge that WeatherTech says keeps them from curving in. Channels carry water and spills to a lower reservoir, and retention devices plus anti-skid nibs stop it from sliding.
WeatherTech says it is made in the USA from 100% recyclable material without latex, PVC, cadmium, or lead. It comes in four colors: black, gray, tan, and cocoa.
It carries WeatherTech’s Lifetime Limited Warranty for the original purchaser and the original vehicle.
Example fit: WeatherTech 44697-1-4IM is the front and second-row set for an F-150 SuperCrew with front bucket seats, a carpet floor, and no fold-flat rear storage.
Catch: WeatherTech’s warranty excludes commercial use, so a true work truck gets less backing here. WeatherTech also still sells the original FloorLiner, which is the stiffer, thermoformed liner. Order the one named FloorLiner HP.
This is the pick when price leads and you still want a liner made for your exact truck.
3W says its liners are 100% TPE, which it calls Thorex, made by injection molding and fit by 3D laser scanning each vehicle.
3W says the material is odorless and that its mats are certified to the Global Recycled Standard with at least 50% recycled content.
3W splits its F-150 SuperCrew sets by whether the truck has the factory folding under-seat storage box. Both sets are for carpet floors and front bucket seats, and 3W says they do not fit vinyl floors.
3W backs its mats with a lifetime warranty for the original purchaser and the original vehicle, and it is not transferable.
Example fit: the set for a 2015–2026 F-150 or F-150 Lightning SuperCrew with the folding under-seat storage box.
Catch: 3W says the mats can arrive folded and may need a day or two flat in the sun, or gentle heat from a hair dryer, before they lie flat. 3W also sells the F-150 set in a standard version and a Pro version with higher side edges and an aluminum footrest plate, so check which one you are ordering.
Every spec in this table comes from the makers’ own pages, and the last row is our call. We mark a spec Not listed when no maker publishes it.
WeatherTech FloorLiner HP vs Husky X-act Contour vs 3W, by maker claims
Spec
WeatherTech FloorLiner HP
Husky X-act Contour
3W
Material
Rubber-like TPE, injection-molded
ProCore formula with a DuraGrip surface
100% TPE (Thorex), injection-molded
How it is fit
Laser measured by year, make, and model
3D laser-scanned to the floor
3D laser scanning of each vehicle
Edge
High walls with a beveled edge
Raised FormFit Edge
Edge-to-edge coverage, with higher edges on the Pro version
Lip height in inches
Not listed
Not listed
Not listed
Grip
Retention devices and anti-skid nibs
StayPut nibs and factory retention posts
Anti-slip texture and nubs
Where it is made
Made in the USA
Made in the USA
Designed in the USA
Warranty
Lifetime Limited, original purchaser and vehicle
Limited lifetime, original purchaser and vehicle
Lifetime, original purchaser and vehicle, not transferable
Commercial use
Excluded from the warranty
Not listed as an exclusion
Not listed as an exclusion
Other line from the same brand
Original FloorLiner, rigid and thermoformed
WeatherBeater, firmer and lower priced
Double Layer Carpet version
Example set on this page
44697-1-4IM, F-150 SuperCrew without fold-flat storage
53468, F-150 SuperCrew with fold-flat storage
F-150 SuperCrew with the storage box
Our call
Buy for a clean truck or a color match
Buy for most trucks and any work truck
Buy when price comes first
Material and feel
All three are molded liners with raised edges, not flat mats. The difference is in how the makers describe the material. WeatherTech says FloorLiner HP is a rubber-like TPE with a soft-touch feel. Husky says X-act Contour is the softest liner in its lineup, more than 10% softer than its WeatherBeater line in the lab tests it cites. 3W says its 100% TPE is lighter, odorless, and more flexible than traditional rubber.
None of the three makers publishes a test against the other two brands. That means no maker-backed answer exists for which brand is softest or toughest across the board. What the makers do say is how each liner compares with its own sibling. WeatherTech’s original FloorLiner uses a rigid HDTE material that is thermoformed, and FloorLiner HP is the more flexible step up. Husky WeatherBeater uses Husky’s ProGard formula, and X-act Contour is the softer, more flexible step up.
Fit, coverage, and the lip
All three makers build each liner for a specific vehicle, and all three ask similar questions before you order. On a pickup, that means the cab, the floor type, the front seats, and the rear floor. 3W, for example, sells separate F-150 SuperCrew sets for trucks with and without the folding under-seat storage box, and it says the set made for trucks without the box will not lie flat in a truck that has one.
WeatherTech says FloorLiner HP covers the bottom, front, back, and sides of the footwell. Husky says its FormFit Edge is a raised outer lip that forms a high wall along the door sills and footwells. 3W lists edge-to-edge coverage, and its Pro version adds what 3W calls extended high edges. None of the three makers lists a lip height in inches, so be wary of any number you see quoted for one of these liners.
All three go straight on the vehicle floor. 3W says to remove the existing floor mats before you install its liners, and WeatherTech says the same for FloorLiner HP and adds that the liner must not interfere with the pedals.
Warranty: read the exclusions
All three call their warranty lifetime, and all three tie it to the original purchaser and the original vehicle. The exclusions are where they split.
WeatherTech lists severe abrasive wear, chemical spills such as gasoline or bleach, accidents, misuse, incorrect installation, fire, and commercial use. It says its warranty covers products bought from WeatherTech or its authorized retailers, and claims need proof of purchase.
Husky says its liners will not break or tear under normal use for the life of the vehicle, as long as the original purchaser still owns it and the liner stays in that vehicle. The warranty is void for misuse, abuse, neglect, accidents, or improper installation, and it does not cover abnormal wear and tear.
3W covers defects, cracking or tearing not caused by outside damage, failed retention clips or nubs, and fit problems caused by a manufacturing error. It excludes normal wear and fading, accidents, fire, chemical spills, pet damage, and improper installation, and it may ask for proof of purchase.
For a truck that earns its keep, the commercial-use line is the one that matters, and only WeatherTech lists it.
Which brand to buy for your truck
Ford F-150: the three cards above use F-150 SuperCrew sets, so the comparison applies directly. Our 2021–2026 F-150 floor mats guide matches each liner to your cab and rear floor.
Chevy Silverado 1500: our 2019–2026 Silverado 1500 floor mats guide picks Husky WeatherBeater by cab and keeps 2019 Silverado 1500 LD owners, who have the older body, out of the wrong set. Husky lists the 94021 set for many 2019–2026 Chevy and GMC trucks.
Ram 1500: our 2019–2026 Ram 1500 floor mats guide picks Husky WeatherBeater for the Crew Cab and splits the sets at the 2025 model year. It also keeps Ram 1500 Classic owners out of the wrong fit.
Toyota Tacoma: our 2024–2026 Tacoma floor mats guide picks WeatherTech FloorLiner HP 441846-1-3IM for the Double Cab with an automatic and the gas engine, with Husky WeatherBeater 94271 as the alternative. Hybrid, XtraCab, and manual trucks need other parts.
Toyota Tundra, Super Duty, and other trucks: we do not have a year-specific mats guide for these yet. WeatherTech, Husky, and 3W all sell by year, make, and cab, so use each maker’s vehicle selector and apply the verdict above to the set it shows you.
Universal trim-to-fit mats. All three brands here make liners for a named truck. A mat you cut with scissors will not follow the floor the same way.
The wrong line from the right brand. WeatherTech’s original FloorLiner is not FloorLiner HP, and Husky WeatherBeater is not X-act Contour. WeatherBeater is a fine liner, and our Silverado and Ram picks use it, but do not order it thinking you are getting X-act Contour.
The wrong rear-floor version. A SuperCrew or Crew Cab with a factory storage box under the rear seat takes a different rear liner. 3W says the wrong version will not lie flat.
A carpet-floor set in a vinyl-floor truck. Husky lists the 94021 set for carpet floors only, and 3W says its F-150 sets do not fit vinyl floors.
A liner on top of your old mats. WeatherTech and 3W both say to remove existing floor mats before you install their liners.
Mixing up 3W and 3D MAXpider. The names look alike, but they are separate brands. Check that the product name says 3W before you order.
FAQ
Which is better, WeatherTech, Husky, or 3W?
For most trucks, and for any work truck, we would buy the Husky X-act Contour. WeatherTech FloorLiner HP is the pick for a truck you keep clean or want to color-match, and 3W is the pick when price comes first.
Is Husky X-act Contour better than WeatherTech FloorLiner HP?
For a truck that works, yes, because WeatherTech’s warranty excludes commercial use and Husky’s warranty does not list that exclusion. WeatherTech’s advantages are high walls with a beveled edge and four colors. Neither maker publishes a test against the other.
Is 3W as good as WeatherTech?
On paper, they are close. 3W says its liner is injection-molded TPE fit by 3D laser scanning, and it carries a lifetime warranty for the original purchaser and vehicle. WeatherTech says FloorLiner HP is made in the USA, while 3W says its liners are designed in the USA. 3W is our budget pick, and WeatherTech is our pick for a truck you keep clean.
Which brand has the highest lip?
None of the three publishes a lip height in inches. WeatherTech describes high walls with a beveled edge, Husky describes a raised FormFit Edge, and 3W lists edge-to-edge coverage with higher edges on its Pro version.
Does WeatherTech’s warranty cover a work truck?
WeatherTech’s Lifetime Limited Warranty lists commercial use as an exclusion. Husky’s and 3W’s warranties do not list commercial use, which is why we put the Husky on a work truck.
What is the difference between WeatherTech FloorLiner and FloorLiner HP?
The original FloorLiner uses a rigid HDTE material that is thermoformed. FloorLiner HP is an injection-molded, rubber-like TPE with anti-skid nibs underneath. FloorLiner HP is the one we compare here.
What is the difference between Husky X-act Contour and WeatherBeater?
X-act Contour is Husky’s premium line, with Husky’s ProCore formula and a DuraGrip surface. In lab tests Husky cites, it was about 22% more flexible, more than 10% softer, and about 20% faster to clean than WeatherBeater. Husky describes WeatherBeater as its firmer, lower-priced line.
Do these brands fit a Silverado, Ram, or Tundra?
All three sell liners by year, make, and cab. Our Silverado 1500 and Ram 1500 guides pick Husky WeatherBeater sets by cab and year. We do not have a Tundra guide yet, so use each maker’s vehicle selector.
Is 3W the same as 3D MAXpider?
No. They are separate brands with separate websites, and everything about 3W on this page comes from 3W’s own pages.